What I Should Have Said at the Hardware Store

This is about a fight my father and I had over a fence post, and the eleven years it took me to understand it wasn't about the fence at all.

I was twenty-three, home from a job that wasn't working out, staying in my old room longer than either of us wanted to admit. My father asked me to help him replace some rotted posts along the back line. I said I would. Then I didn't, three Saturdays running, because I was busy being quietly miserable about my life and didn't have room left over for his.

The third Saturday he went to the hardware store alone, bought the posts himself, and when I found out I got defensive instead of sorry — told him he should've just asked again, like it was his failure for not insisting. He looked at me the way you look at someone you don't recognize for a second. Then he said, "I didn't think I should have to," and went back out to dig the holes by himself in July heat he had no business being out in at sixty-one.

We didn't talk about it again. That's the kind of family we were — the silence did the apologizing nobody wanted to say out loud. I told myself I'd make it right later, help with the next project, be better next time. There was always supposed to be a next time.

He died four years ago this past spring, and it wasn't the big things I thought about at the funeral. It was the fence. The way he dug those holes alone. The particular shame of watching someone do something for you that you promised to do for them.

It took me a long time — longer than it should have — to understand that he wasn't angry about the posts. He was telling me, in the only language men like him had, that he'd noticed I was drowning and didn't know how to reach me, so he reached for the one thing he could fix with his hands. The fence was never the fence. It was him trying to be near me without having to say so.

I know that now the way you know things too late to use them — which is to say, I know it the way you carry something instead of the way you spend it.

What I've made peace with isn't the moment. I can't undo an afternoon in July. What I've made peace with is that he knew. Somewhere in the not-saying, in the digging, in the two of us circling each other without landing on the words, he knew I loved him, and I knew he loved me, and neither of us needed the fence to prove it — we just didn't know how to take the proof any other way.

Scott Andrew Alpaugh writes about memory because memory is where the unfinished conversations go to wait, patiently, until you're finally ready to finish them, even if only with yourself.

I go out back sometimes, at my own house now, and check the fence posts. Not because they need it. Because it's the closest thing I have to saying it to him properly, late as it is.


More at scottandrewalpaugh.com, andrewalpaugh.com, and scottalpaugh.com.


Written by Scott Andrew Alpaugh — technology professional and entrepreneur based in Greenville, South Carolina. Also at andrewalpaugh.com and scottalpaugh.com.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Trisomy 13 - Dignity and Grace in Life and Death

Be Kind